YouTube is an incoherent as well as an extremely biased organisation.
Just over a week ago I uploaded a very brief newsreel about the funeral of
Shiekh Abbas Musawi, an early leader of the Lebanese political party which has
a military wing.
I had discovered the reel late last year but uploaded it just before the
delayed funeral in February of Musawi's successor Sheikh Hassan Nasrallah.
But when I noticed that the video did not materialise, I checked and discovered
that YouTube had frozen the upload, claiming that it was suspected of
infringing their policy on "violent organisations".
I did not appeal until a few days ago.
Their joke of an "appeal" does allow you to provide any written
points, but I presume that a human intervenes at this point.
My appeal was allowed.
However, the appeal only allowed the newsreel to stay on my channel as a
"private" upload, meaning that it could not be viewed by the public.
I appealed again.
This time, and again with I presume human intervention, YouTube decided to totally
remove the newsreel and issue. a "warning". A warning is different
from a "strike" which puts a channel at risk of being taken down if
it gets up to 3 strikes.
You will note the arbitrariness of this decision.
1. If you appeal and we don't like the content we will impose a more severe
"punishment".
2. Hassan Nasrallah's funeral was streamed live on numerous YouTube channels
including those in the mainstream.
Was hours of such streaming "glorifying" Hezbollah?
3. I have previously uploaded funerals of the following:
. Bashir Gemayel, the assassinated Maronite Christian warlord
. Naval crew of the Israeli Naval Destroyer INS Eilat
. Memorial service in Israel for the crew of the INS Dakar
I set the INS Dakar video to Maurice Ravel's version of the "Kaddish"
and the Eilat one to Barbra Streisand singing "Avinu Malkeinu".
Gemayel would qualify as having presided over a "terrorist"
organisation. The military wing of the Kataeb Party (or Phalangist Party)
committed several massacres and other forms of terrorism during the Lebanese
Civil War.
Israel as a state has always had a terrorist doctrine which legitimises the
objective of killing innocent civilians during military operations. Israel's
"sacred terrorism" as an early prime minister named Moshe Sharett
termed it, has been set out or acknowledged by a range of its political and
military leaders beginning with David Ben Gurion who recorded in the
Independence Diaries that "women and children" were legitimate
targets and extending to the contemporary "Dahiya Doctrine" (Lebanon)
and "Mowing the Lawn Doctrine" (Gaza), the latter of which has
evolved into an outright policy of genocide.
Frankly, the case that the Israeli state is a terrorist one can be proven
beyond a shadow of doubt.
But the designation of what is a terrorist entity is full of contradictions.
Hezbollah exists because of Israel's repeated invasions of Lebanon and the
long-term Zionist objective of colonising south Lebanon up to the Litani River.
But the United States, at the urging of the Israel lobby in America and Canada,
removed the designation of terrorist organisation from Mojahedin-e-Khalq (MEK),
which targeted American military, diplomatic and corporate personnel during the
era of the Shah because it commits acts of terror against the Islamic
government of Iran.
Anyway, the revelant newsreel is uploaded at my channel on the Rumble platform.
I will find time to write an email and a letter to YouTube HQ reflecting on
what I have jotted down here. They are as loathsome as the arbiters of Facebook
who ruled at the outset of the Russian intervention in Ukraine that posts which
praised the neo-Nazi Azov Battalion in the context of the conflict would not be
censured.
That just about says it all.
In the meantime, we should all contemplate how a one-minute newsreel about the
funeral of Abbas Musawi in 1992 which would have been broadcast on mainstream
news channels around the world can all of a sudden be considered as praising a
"criminal organisation".
© Adeyinka Makinde (2025)
Adeyinka Makinde is a writer based in London, England.